What Emotional Regulation Really Is — And Why It’s the Foundation of Mental Health
- Christine Walter
- Jan 14
- 5 min read
Emotional regulation isn’t “staying calm.” It isn’t “being positive.” And it definitely isn’t pretending you’re fine.
Emotional regulation is the skill of staying in relationship with your inner experience—so emotions can move through you as information, not hijack you as identity. When regulation is strong, feelings don’t disappear; they become workable. When regulation is weak, even small stressors can feel like a full-body emergency.
Psychology treats emotional regulation as a core human capacity because it influences almost everything: anxiety, depression, burnout, relationships, decision-making, health behaviors, and the ability to repair after conflict. It’s not a “soft skill.” It’s infrastructure.
Emotion regulation is most commonly defined as the processes through which we influence which emotions we have, when we have them, and how we experience and express them.
What Emotional Regulation Is
In the field, emotional regulation includes both conscious and automatic processes—things you do intentionally (like reframing a situation) and things your nervous system does automatically (like bracing, shutting down, or getting activated).
James Gross’s influential model explains that regulation can happen at multiple points in the emotion process—not just after you’re already upset.
The 5 places you can regulate emotion (before it overwhelms you)
This is what makes regulation feel learnable: you have multiple “levers.”
Situation selection (what you choose to enter/avoid)
Situation modification (what you change once you’re in it)
Attentional deployment (what you focus on)
Cognitive change (what you decide it means; reappraisal)
Response modulation (what you do after emotion rises—suppression, breathing, substances, etc.)
Later work expands this into an “extended process” where regulation involves:
noticing you need to regulate,
choosing a strategy,
and implementing it effectively.
What Emotional Regulation Is Not
It’s not suppression
Suppression is forcing emotions down. It might work short-term, but often increases internal strain and can reduce emotional clarity over time. (This is one reason suppression shows up as a “maladaptive” strategy in large-scale reviews.)
It’s not emotional control
Control implies domination. Regulation implies relationship. Emotions are biological signals. Treating them like enemies tends to escalate the system.
It’s not spiritual bypassing
Being “high vibe” is not regulation. Regulation is the ability to stay present with discomfort without becoming destructive—to yourself or others.
What Happens in Your Brain During Regulation
A simple way to understand this: regulation is not “thinking your way out.” It’s changing the brain-body pattern.
When emotion rises—especially fear, shame, anger—threat-related circuitry (including the amygdala) becomes more active. Effective regulation often involves recruiting prefrontal systems involved in meaning-making, perspective-taking, and control. Neuroimaging meta-analyses of emotion regulation show coordinated connectivity between the amygdala and prefrontal regions during down-regulation, particularly in cognitive reappraisal.
In human language:
your brain learns to say: “This is intense, but it’s not danger,”
and your body learns to stand down.
Why Emotional Dysregulation Feels So Personal (But Isn’t)
When you’re dysregulated, it can feel like:
“This is who I am.”
“I’m too much.”
“I’m not safe.”
“I have to fix this immediately.”
But dysregulation is often a state, not a self. It’s your system doing its best with the tools it has.
What makes this topic urgent is that emotional regulation is transdiagnostic—a core mechanism across many forms of suffering. Meta-analytic evidence links certain regulation strategies (rumination, avoidance, suppression) with more psychopathology, while strategies like reappraisal and problem solving are linked with less.
This doesn’t mean “reappraise and you’ll be cured.” It means:
regulation patterns shape risk,
and changing patterns changes outcomes.
The Hidden Health Cost: When Your Mind Keeps Your Body Stressed
One of the most important findings in health psychology is that stress doesn’t require a current threat. Your body can stay activated through repetitive negative thinking—worry, rumination, replaying conversations.
The perseverative cognition hypothesis explains how repeated mental activation of stressors can prolong physiological stress responses (even after the event ends) and contribute to health risk over time.
In plain terms:If your mind keeps reopening the file, your nervous system keeps paying the bill.
The Key Most Articles Miss: Flexibility Beats “The Best Technique”
Many people search for the single best method—breathing, mindset, meditation, tapping.
The research trend points to something more nuanced: regulatory flexibility—your ability to match strategy to context. Bonanno and Burton describe flexibility as involving context sensitivity, having a repertoire of strategies, and adjusting based on feedback.
This matters because:
distraction might help in the short term during acute stress,
while reappraisal might help later when you’re stable,
and boundary-setting might be the real regulation move in relational dynamics.
What Works: Evidence-Based Emotion Regulation Strategies
A major meta-analysis (over 300 experimental comparisons) evaluated the effectiveness of strategies derived from the process model and found that strategies differ in effectiveness depending on outcomes measured (experience, behavior, physiology).
Translation: Not all regulation strategies are equal—and the same strategy won’t be best in every moment.
A Practical Framework:
The 3 Moves That Build Regulation Fast
These are grounded in research and built to be usable.
1) Name what’s happening (precision reduces intensity)
When you can name the emotion specifically (hurt vs. angry; ashamed vs. stressed), you reduce global threat. This supports the “identification” step in regulation—knowing what you’re working with.
Try:
“I’m activated.”
“I’m disappointed.”
“I feel dismissed.”
“This is shame.”
2) Downshift the body first (then use the mind)
If your system is in high arousal, cognition is limited. Use a body-first tool:
longer exhales than inhales for 2 minutes
a brisk 5-minute walk
shaking out tension (30–60 seconds)Then decide what meaning you’re assigning.
This is how you stop rumination from turning into prolonged stress physiology.
3) Choose the right lever
Ask one question:
“Do I need to change the situation, my attention, my meaning, or my response?”
Examples:
Situation: boundary, request, leaving the room
Attention: stop doom-scrolling, change input
Meaning: reappraise, widen perspective
Response: breathe, move, pause before speaking
Flexibility is the win.
Quick Self-Assessment: Are You Regulated or Performing Regulation?
You might be dysregulated if you:
need to “win” the conversation to feel okay
feel urgency to fix feelings immediately
replay interactions long after they’re over
feel numb or shut down when emotions rise
swing between over-functioning and collapse
You might be regulated if you:
can pause without panicking
can feel discomfort without self-abandoning
can stay kind and boundaried simultaneously
recover faster after stress
can repair conflict without shame spirals
A 7-Day Regulation Practice (Simple, Not Performative)
Daily (5 minutes):
Identify one emotion (precision)
Do 90 seconds of long exhales (downshift)
Choose one lever: situation / attention / meaning / response (action)
At the end of the week, notice:
Do you recover faster? React less? Feel more internal space?
That’s regulation taking root.
About Christine Walter Coaching
At Christine Walter Coaching, I help individuals and couples strengthen emotional regulation and relationship repair by working with both the mind and the nervous system—so you can respond with clarity instead of reactivity.
Blogs you might enjoy:
References
Gross, J. J. (1998). The Emerging Field of Emotion Regulation: An Integrative Review (PDF):
https://emotion.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/1353/2021/11/Gross-1998-The-Emerging-Field-of-Emotion-Regulation-An-Integrative-Review.pdf
Gross, J. J. (2015). Emotion Regulation: Current Status and Future Prospects (PDF):
https://www.johnnietfeld.com/uploads/2/2/6/0/22606800/gross_2015.pdf
(JSTOR PDF version):
https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/43865705.pdf
Aldao, A., Nolen-Hoeksema, S., & Schweizer, S. (2010). Emotion-regulation strategies across psychopathology: A meta-analytic review (ScienceDirect):
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0272735809001597
Author copy PDF:
https://gruberpeplab.com/teaching/psych131_summer2013/documents/Lecture17_Aldao2010_Emotionregulationstrategies.pdf
Webb, T. L., Miles, E., & Sheeran, P. (2012). Dealing With Feeling: A meta-analysis of emotion regulation strategies (PDF):
https://is.muni.cz/el/med/jaro2022/BKSC041/123791601/Dealing_With_Feeling_A_Meta-Analysis_of_20160404-4562-4y8p03-with-cover-page-v2.pdf
Brosschot, J. F., Gerin, W., & Thayer, J. F. (2006). The perseverative cognition hypothesis (ScienceDirect):
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022399905002151
Bonanno, G. A., & Burton, C. L. (2013). Regulatory Flexibility (PDF):
https://www.tc.columbia.edu/faculty/gab38/faculty-profile/files/2013_Bonanno_Burton_REGULATORY_FLEXIBLITY.pdf
Amygdala–prefrontal connectivity during emotion regulation: meta-analysis (ScienceDirect):
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S002839322100018X
Open PDF copy:
https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/395672906.pdf
Comments